Ajarn Brett’s Blog

Scattered Speculations of a Wanderer in Thai Cyberspace

Sacred and Profane Bangkok

February 12th, 2010 by · 5 Comments · Culture, Social, Theory

Peter Arnell, the Branding Guru

Peter Arnell, the "Branding Guru"

I was intrigued to read a story in today’s edition of The Nation online newspaper about the American advertising executive, Peter Arnell, the so-called “brand guru” of Madison Ave, who is offering to “rebrand” Thailand. Arnell is the brains behind the rebranding campaigns of several high profile global companies including Pepsi and he believes that Thailand would benefit from his creative genius. Thailand, he asserts, is “is not the place of wacky bars or crazy nightlife that most people think” but rather “a sensible, harmonious, calm, peaceful and respectful country driven by humanity and a soulfulness, unlike any other place in the world.” Amazingly, Arnell was able to come to this realization in record speed. Prior to December last year he had never even set foot in the country but, after a whirlwind 12-day tour –in which he came, he saw, he took 7,000 pictures– he fell in love with the place. So now he’s back, ensconced in a suite at the Oriental Hotel, and is making a magnanimous offer to the Thai government to help save the nation from its image problem of gogo bars and hedonism by giving it a new “unique, easily recognisable symbol, based on the distinctive temple spires of its classic architecture.”  It is a heartwarming gesture of extraordinary charity and all Arnell is seeking in return is a mere US$10 million. Hmmm, yeah right….

Bangkok: a place of wacky bars and crazy nightlife?

Bangkok: a "place of wacky bars and crazy nightlife"?

Anyhoo, it’s interesting that Arnell should identify the very same two images — temples and prostitution — that we also discussed as major parts of Bangkok’s representational profile in tutorials this week. While Arnell’s assessment would seem to suggest that the two are basically incompatible, there is another way of thinking about them.

Emile Durkheim

Emile Durkheim

Emile Durkheim, whom you will recall from this week’s lecture as one of the pioneering figures of European sociology, argued that most, if not all, cultures possess a central binary opposition between what he termed the sacred and the profane and that they use this opposition to organize their ideological worldview and, by extension, their social relations . As its name might suggest the sacred is that which a society deems to be holy or special. In most societies, it is the province of religion but in secular societies the role of the sacred can arguably be assumed by other institutions that obtain a religious-like status (government, monarchy, science, medicine). The profane, on the other hand, is basically the sacred’s opposite: the mundane and the ordinary. The world of the sacred and the world of the profane exclude each other, Durkheim argues, and are mutually antagonistic. However, they also need each other in order to define themselves and assume cultural value. Thus, for example, the sacred only makes sense in terms of what it is not (i.e the profane) and vice versa.

The other side of Bangkok

The "other" side of Bangkok

In Thai culture, temples or วัด are obviously sites of the sacred and they are marked clearly as such in terms of their spatial organization. When we enter a วัด we effectively make a physical and psychological movement from a spatial register of the profane (the everyday life of the city and the street) into a separate space of the sacred: we enter through the gated walls of the วัด, remove our shoes and pass through a door or even series of doors into the interior of the temple where we modify our normal (profane) behaviour: we talk in whispers, get onto the floor, bow, etc. Moreover, there are certain spaces and/or objects of the วัด that are prohibited to laypeople and can only be accessed by monks who are of course people who have taken vows to renounce the world of the profane (sex, money, power, possessions) and live entirely in the word of the sacred…well, at least in theory if not always practice!  :D   But the spatial sacredness of the วัด still depends on the spatial profanity of the world outside its walls in order to have meaning and value. If there was no profane world then the วัด wouldn’t be sacred or even special. In this way, the two images popularly associated with Bangkok — temples and gogo bars — are possibly more complementary than they might at first seem. Indeed, one could say they depend on each other, at least in terms of definitional logic, and so might be seen as twin icons of Thailand’s representational construction in the popular imaginary.

Tags: ····

The Death of the Author

January 30th, 2010 by · 4 Comments · Culture, Current Affairs, Theory

I have been intrigued in recent days over the high-profile media coverage afforded the death of the American author, J.D. Salinger. He passed away last Wednesday at his home in New Hampshire at the ripe old age of 91. Newspapers around the world are scrambling over themselves to write about him and the internet is abuzz with discussion. Indeed, it seems every second one of my Facebook friends has posted some status update wishing him Vale or RIP.

J.D. Salinger

J.D. Salinger

At a certain level, this is understandable. Salinger is largely known for his ground-breaking 1951 novel, Catcher in the Rye, which has become a classic of modern American literature and required reading on high school and university curricula around the globe. The book is also widely regarded as the exemplary coming-of-age novel, cherished by millions of adolescents who have identified deeply with its evocative portrayal of disaffected youth. I myself was one of them. I first read the book as a gawky 13 year old and was convinced that Salinger had written my story.

The thing is, though, that Salinger never really wrote much other than Catcher. It was his debut novel and, while he penned a couple of novellas and a series of short stories in the years that followed, none of them were quite able to match the literary and popular success of his first book. He stopped publishing altogether in the mid-60s and withdrew from public life. Indeed, he lived for much of the past 40 years as a recluse in his home in the Northeastern US, refusing to give interviews or even receive visitors.

Interestingly, though, his withdrawal from public life actually helped fuel Salinger’s literary celebrity. A whole mythic cult developed around him and stories circulated about his life and what he was doing. One of the stories was that he was still writing furiously but refused to allow anything to be published and that his house is filled with manuscripts waiting to see the light of day after his death. Another story claimed he was a chronic perfectionist who was doomed by the success of his first novel because he felt that nothing would ever be able to top it and he was forever locked thereafter in a vicious cycle of writing and destroying. I guess we will find out soon enough if any of these stories are actually true.

In the late-60s, Roland Barthes — who of course you all know and love so well by now — wrote an influential essay titled, “The Death of the Author”. It was principally a manifesto for a new style of literary criticism, one that abandoned what is often called “the intentionalist fallacy” or the idea that the aim of literary interpretation is to discover what the author really meant. However, it also deconstructed “the myth of the author” that has developed in modern Western cultures. As Barthes sees it, the notion we have today of the author as a singular artist whose works spring from an inner reserve of creativity or artistic soul is a product of post-Cartesian Western ideologies of individualism and Romanticist notions of the artist as an independent genius with acute powers of observation. Against which, he argues that artistic creativity is actually collective or structural in nature. Like all subjects, an author or artist is a determinate product of culture and history, shaped by social forces beyond his/her control or even knowledge. Thus, while an artist may have special talents, s/he is still really just a channel or conduit for social and historical discourses and that the true “author” of a text is ultimately culture and history. As he writes in a famous passage, “Text is a tissue of quotations drawn from the innumerable centres of culture.” Indeed, he ultimately claims that any sense of unity in a text is given by the reader or viewer not the author-producer, though the reader is also nothing more than a conduit shaped by culture and history as well. It’s a radical argument that isn’t easy to grasp at first but it does offer a useful challenge to the ways in which we are traditionally conditioned to think about cultural production. If you are feeling game, you can read Barthes essay here online, but of course make sure you have first completed all your required readings for next week’s class of “Cultures of Everyday Life”… :D

Still, as attested by the cultural response to the passing of J.D. Salinger, while the author may be dead, his/her “myth” is still well and truly alive and kicking…

Yang Liu’s Pictograms

January 19th, 2010 by · 2 Comments · Culture, Media

I thought some of you might appreciate looking further at the work of Yang Liu, the Chinese-German graphic artist whose series of pictograms we looked at in tutorials last week.

Yang Liu

Yang Liu

While her striking series of pictograms about Western and Asian cultural differences is arguably her most well-known work, she is a very verstaile artist whose work encompasses a range of topics and styles. I am particularly taken with some of the poster design work she has done for various agencies and corporations.

Here is one she did for the Berlin Zoo:

Yang Liu, Poster for Berlin Zoo and Aquarium

Yang Liu, Poster for Berlin Zoo and Aquarium

And another for Asian tourism:

Yang Liu, Discover Asia

Yang Liu, Discover Asia

Much of the power of Yang’s work comes from its visual simplicity. This arguably leads to a certain degree of reductivism at the conceptual level. As we discussed last week, some of her images in the Cultural Differences series trade in two-dimensional stereotypes and thus gloss over nuances and complexities. Nevertheless, their simplicity makes them not only visually arresting but also intellectually provocative in the best sense as art that provokes thought and discussion.

Yang Liu Exhibition

Yang Liu Exhibition

If you were to design a similar series profiling Thai and farang cultural differences what sort of things might you include?

Tags: ··

Ajarn Brett’s Philosophy of Assessment…or Why Is He So ดุ and ใจร้าย When Grading Our Essays?

January 9th, 2010 by · 3 Comments · Teaching

Unhappy BALAC Student

Unhappy BALAC Student

I have had a number of students come to see me through the week about their results from “Media Cultures” last term. Most complained that they had never received such a low grade before and wanted to know why their results were so low. It’s really quite simple. As was clearly spelled out in the subject syllabus and was reiterated repeatedly in class, I have a very systematic approach to assessment. I prescribe a set of criteria for assessment exercises and then evaluate students’ work against that criteria. The final result received by a student is entirely determined by the extent to which they meet the assessment criteria in their work. Once again, the core criteria I used last term and that I will also be using this term are:

  • an explicit and comprehensive engagement with the topic and/or exercise brief
  • demonstrated knowledge of concepts, theories and arguments profiled in the subject
  • use of appropriate critical and analytic approaches
  • construction of a clear, progressive argument
  • evidence of appropriate scholastic research
  • clarity and fluency of written expression
  • use of appropriate conventions of academic writing such as referencing, bibliography/filmography, etcetera.

These criteria are based on the fundamental components of scholarly research and writing and, thus, are the sort of things that should characterize all academic coursework. How you perform is ultimately dependent on how well you realize these criteria. The better the realization, the higher the grade. It’s quite simple, really.

Some students complain that other ajarns don’t levy these criteria or they don’t impose such stringent expectations. Obviously, I can’t talk for other ajarns, I can only talk for myself. If I am strict and if I do impose high expectations, that is because I believe in providing you with quality international education and holding you accountable to the standards of such an education.

I believe that performance in education–as in most areas of life–is directly correlative to standards and expectations. If low standards and expectations are set, then students perform at a low level. However, if high standards are set then students are encouraged to push themselves in order to met them and to perform at their optimal levels. I believe my job as a teacher is to challenge each and every one of you to attain the highest levels of learning that you can and to realize your full potential as students and intellectual beings. That will only happen if I push you and encourage you to work hard and to take your learning and studies seriously.

Rising to the Challenge

Rising to the Challenge

So for those of you who received a low result last term, rather than feeling aggrieved, I would hope that you will take it as a wake-up call about the need to commit seriously to your studies in BALAC. As I said in class the other day, there is no reason that the majority of you aren’t getting As and Bs, instead of Cs and Ds. However, I am not just going to dispense high grades as rewards for poor work or insufficient effort. Not only would this be a disservice to those students who do work hard and who truly merit high grades…but, ultimately, it would be a disservice to all of you because it wouldn’t be holding you to the quality standards that I know you are all fully capable of achieving.

So let’s all resolve to work together this term and turn around the culture of apathy and poor performance that plagued our studies last term. Contrary to popular student perceptions of me as some sort of ใจร้าย ogre :) , I hope you will all know that I am really very ใจดี and that I am committed to helping each and every one of you as best I can. So if you are experiencing difficulties or need extra guidance in terms of your learning needs, please don’t hesitate to come and see me. I promise I won’t bite… :D

อาจารย์Brett ใจดีจริง

อาจารย์Brett ใจดีจริง

Tags: ···

SOS from Mother Nature: The Work of Chris Jordan

November 15th, 2009 by · 2 Comments · Culture, Current Affairs, Media, Photography

Recently, I discovered the work of Chris Jordan, a US-based artist-photographer who uses his work to make thought-provoking statements about contemporary global consumer culture and what it (by which of course I mean “we”) are doing to the planet. In some of his earlier work, Jordan did things like depict landscapes of discarded consumer goods such as this one from his 2005 series, “Intolerable Beauty”, which shows a sea of old cell phones:

Chris Jordan, Cell phones #2, Atlanta 2005

Chris Jordan, Cell phones #2, Atlanta 2005

Or in his 2008 series, “Running the Numbers” he composed very large images made up of thousands of individual photos of a particular commodity, the exact number of which was linked to some statistic of US or global consumerism. For example, the following image is simply called “Plastic Cups” and it depicts one million plastic cups which is the number used on airline flights in the US every six hours. The closer you get to the image, the more you see the individual commodities.

Chris Jordan, Plastic Cups, 2008

Chris Jordan, Plastic Cups, 2008

Chris Jordan, Plastic Cups, 2008 (Partial Zoom)

Chris Jordan, Plastic Cups, 2008 (Partial Zoom)

His latest  series, “Midway: Message from the Gyre” is possibly his most confronting yet. Here is his accompanying description:

These photographs of albatross chicks were made just a few weeks ago on Midway Atoll, a tiny stretch of sand and coral near the middle of the North Pacific. The nesting babies are fed bellies-full of plastic by their parents, who soar out over the vast polluted ocean collecting what looks to them like food to bring back to their young. On this diet of human trash, every year tens of thousands of albatross chicks die on Midway from starvation, toxicity, and choking.

To document this phenomenon as faithfully as possible, not a single piece of plastic in any of these photographs was moved, placed, manipulated, arranged, or altered in any way. These images depict the actual stomach contents of baby birds in one of the world’s most remote marine sanctuaries, more than 2000 miles from the nearest continent.

As I was looking at these images , I was reminded of the time last year when I was in Phuket, cruising in a boat off the coast , and I saw a veritable river of trash flowing from the shore into the open sea. I don’t mean like ‘a plastic bottle here and a piece of paper there.’ It was a thick, steady stream of garbage that was carried on the current from the island and continued out to sea. I thought to myself at that time, ‘Where does this rubbish go?’ Now I know…

Chris Jordan, Midway: Message from the Gyre 2009

Chris Jordan, Midway: Message from the Gyre 2009

Here’s the link to Chris Jordan’s website:
http://www.chrisjordan.com

For the ‘click’ impaired, here’s a YouTube video of his recent series:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gbqJ6FLfaJc&hd=1

Bangkok World Film Festival

November 10th, 2009 by · No Comments · Culture, Events, film

I’d meant to post about this earlier but the BKK World Film Festival is currently playing at Paragon till Sunday. I have been so busy that I’ve only had a chance to see one film so far but I am hoping to catch at least a few more over the next four days before the festival ends.

The one film I have seen so far is Visage (Face) by the Malaysian-Taiwanese director, Tsai Ming-liang. Tsai is a high profile art filmmaker who has developed an esteemed international reputation for challenging but extraordinarily beautiful work. For example, he is known for his use of extreme long takes and what the French call le temps mort which basically means ‘dead time’ and refers to a long stretch of cinematic time where nothing much really happens and the camera simply observes the scene. Many viewers find this hard to take and it’s not uncommon for people to walk out during screenings of his films. Personally, I love his work. You have to put a little effort into watching his films but I find them rather meditative and very rewarding.

Visage is his latest work and it was made in collaboration with the Louvre Museum and funding from the French government. It features many famous figures and from and references to French cinema, especially the New Wave of the 50s and 60s. At 138 minutes, it’s arguably a tad too long and, while I don’t think it is one of Tsai’s best works, it is a very rich and evocative film with some truly gorgeous moments. Highly recommended!

The other film I am really looking forward to is เจ้านกกระจอก Mundane History by อโนชา สุวิชากรพงษ์ Anocha ‘Mai’ Suwichakornpong. Anocha is a local indie filmmaker who has made a number of interesting short films before but this is her first feature length film. She worked on it for several years and it premiered to great acclaim last month at the celebrated Pusan International Film Festival is South Korea. From what I know it tells a simple story about a male nurse who comes to care for a young Thai teenager who has been rendered a paraplegic. This story is used as a metaphoric screen for exploring all sorts of issues to do with Thai politics and history. That sounds far fetched, I know, but, by all accounts, it’s magnificent. It was the opening film for the BKK World Film Festival last Friday. I was actually invited to the opening but had to go out of town so couldn’t attend. The film is screening again on Thursday night and I am determined to catch up with it then.

Lots of other great films in the festival as well, so if you’ve got some spare time between now and Sunday, check out the festival website and treat yourself to something different. You could even blog about it afterward… :)

Loy Kratong

November 3rd, 2009 by · 3 Comments · Culture, Social

Well another Loy Kratong has come and gone. This is the third Loy Kratong I have celebrated in Thailand and it is by far and away my favourite local holiday. As with last year I just went to the park near where I live. They have a pond there and set up lots of stalls with food and various other items for sale. It has a really pleasant atmosphere: buzzing with excitement but not as overcrowded as some parts of BKK can get. Best of all, my kratong managed to stay both alight and afloat so here’s hoping it’s a good sign for the year to come… :)

I could lie and tell you that I made it myself...

I could lie and tell you that I made it myself...


Wishin' and hopin' and thinkin' and prayin'

Wishin' and hopin' and thinkin' and prayin'


Kratong Graveyard

Kratong Graveyard

The Power of Montage

October 30th, 2009 by · No Comments · Culture, film, Media

A friend just sent me a link to this video on YouTube. It’s made by the Swedish former-tennis champion turned fashion guru, Bjorn Borg. Its an excellent example of how editing can be used to create meanings and control viewer expectations. It’s also an excellent example of ideological assumptions…and their subversion. :-)

Practicing What I Preach: The Virtues of Blogging

October 30th, 2009 by · No Comments · Information Communication Technology, Media, Teaching

Uncle Sam and Ajarn Brett Wants You...!!

Uncle Sam and Ajarn Brett Want You...!!

I know that I have been exhorting all of you to post more diligently to your blogs, all the while leaving my own blog rather silent. My excuse is that I have been inordinately busy the last few weeks…and, besides, unlike you, I’m not getting graded on my blog so there’s not as much incentive!! ๕๕๕ :)

Anyway, I will endeavour to be a bit more conscientious and post more frequently. I thought this might be a good opportunity though to briefly reiterate the aims and benefits of blogging and why I have mandated it as a core assessment exercise in this subject.

There has been a lot of very positive research on the use of blogging as an educational resource. In fact, I myself published a co-authored paper last year based on experiences of using blogging with a large freshman media course while I was working at the University of Melbourne before coming to Chula. Almost without exception, the research highlights that blogging is useful for promoting what is known as higher-order learning, that is to say learning that is active, deep and enduring.

The reasons for this are multiple but two are generally singled out as most important. The first of these is continuous learning. One of the problems with conventional modes of assessment is that they encourage students to focus their learning energies artificially either on dedicated periods of assessment only (i.e. exam periods) and/or only those knowledges and skills on which they are being directly assessed. This doesn’t really foster a deep or holistic approach to education. Because blogging is on-going and something that students do on a regular basis–hmmm, well, at least, ideally :) –it encourages a more continuous process of learning as well as greater attention to a fuller range of subject concerns and not just those contained in exams or essays.

The second issue often cited as an instrinsic educational benefit of blogging is what is known as empowered learning. Older models of education tend to be inherently passivizing. You know, where the teacher stands at the front and students just sit their like sponges soaking up everything he/she says or, as is more often the case, where they just zone out and fall asleep. Boy, does that mental picture seem familiar!! Or in a similar vein,  where students diligently read their textbooks or whatever other sources they may be using and slavishly commit everything to memory without actively processing it. Newer educational trends stress the need to put students in the driver’s seat and to get them to take ownership of the learning process. Blogs can facilitate this because they are spaces for individual expression over which students have full control. They are the ones who decide what to say and how to say it and, by so doing, progressively start to assume possession of the learning process. Because blogging is also generally very personal it further endorses a personalization of learning and helps students to relate to the material being studied by making it part of their everyday lives and practices and not just something encountered in classrooms or libraries.

That’s the theory, in any case! But as with any theory, it is only ever valuable to the extent that it is put into practice…so hopefully you will all take the initiative to be more active and ethusiastic with your blogging from hereon in. Happy typing everyone… :)

2009 Bangkok International Film Festival

September 19th, 2009 by · 8 Comments · Events, film, Media

In this week’s class, I emphasised the importance of opening yourself up to different traditions of filmmaking other than the dominant mainstream kind that is usually seen in the mutiplex and/or on TV. Not only is this a good way to expose yourself to different cinematic and cultural perspectives and ideas but it also helps to develop and finesse your powers of media literacy. A golden opportunity to do this is about to arrive in the form of the annual Bangkok International Film Festival which starts next week. Details about films and screenings are available on the festival website.

BKK International Film Festival

BKK International Film Festival

Film festivals are big business and while the BKK Festival is a relatively new one, it is developing as an important regional showcase of world cinema with a particular focus on the SE Asian filmmaking. The BKK Festival has recently been embroiled in a good deal of controversy because of corruption allegations against two of the Festival’s former US directors but it seems to be rebounding well and this year’s lineup is pretty impressive.

Over six days from 24-30 September, the 2009 Festival will screen some 80 films from around the world. Most of these films will never be screened elsewhere in Thailand and probably also won’t be available on DVD so, for many of us, this will be the the only chance to see these films. The Festival features a number of different programs ranging from World Cinema, Regional SE Asian Showcase, Thai Panorama through to Documentary and Animation. I am hoping to get to see as many films as I can but unfortunately the Festival is on at a very busy time for me workwise so we shall have to see how it goes.

I am particularly keen to see  Kinatay by the Filipino director Brillante Mendoza; 35 Shots of Rum, the latest from celebrated French auteur, Claire Denis; and, The Time That Remains from Palestinian-Israeli director, Elia Suleiman. The Festival is also hosting a retrospective of the films of the classic Thai director,

Cherd Songsris The Scar

Cherd Songsri's The Scar

Cherd Songsri including Muen and Rid (อำแดงเหมือนกับนายริด), Ploy Talay (พลอยทะเล) , and his masterwork The Scar (แผลเก่า). I have seen most of Cherd’s films before but only on DVD so I am very much looking forward to seeing at least one or two of them on the big screen. In addition, there are a host of very interesting looking films in the documentary program.

Without doubt the film I am most looking forward to is Agrarian Utopia, the much awaited new entry from Thai indie filmmaker, Uruphong Raksasad. Uruphong is a fairly new but incredibly innovative filmmaker whose work is typified by an engaging mix of personal storytelling, political critique and beautifully composed digital cinematography. He studied Mass Comm at Thammasat and worked for several years as an editor in the mainstream Thai film industry but then returned to his home village in Chiang Rai where he has devoted himself to making intensely personal, local films. His earlier film, Stories from the North (2005), was a stunning debut feature so it will be interesting to see how he follows that up with Agrarian Utopia. To see the trailer for this film click below:

Trailer for Agrarian Utopia

Ah so many films, so little time! Anyway, do try and get to see some of the films in the Festival and, who knows, we may even bump into each other…

Agrarian Utopia

Agrarian Utopia